Mentally challenged man's life sentence set aside.

LAHORE -- The Lahore High Court has set aside the life sentence of a 'mentally ill' man in a murder case of his wife and directed the trial court to determine, in view of the Supreme Court's observations, the capability of the convict to face trial.

Niaz Khan was tried by a sessions court which held him guilty under section 302(b) of PPC in the impugned judgement passed on Feb 15, 2021 and sentenced to imprisonment for life with compensation of Rs100,000 payable to legal heirs of the deceased.

The man challenged the conviction before the high court and his counsel mainly argued that the appellant was incapable to face trial or defend himself. He said the trial court was cognisant of this fact but could not determine this issue under the law, which caused miscarriage of justice.

Allowing the appeal of the convict, Justice Sardar Ahmad Naeem observes in his judgement that the record shows that the trial court noted that the appellant appeared to be abnormal when produced during the trial. A medical board filed its report to the trial court suggesting behavioral disorder/schizophrenia but the court concluded that the appellant was fit to stand trial.

Justice Naeem regrets that at the time of final arguments, the mental illness was argued by the defence counsel but the impugned judgment is totally silent about this aspect of the case. He notes that despite the fact that the trial court itself referred the appellant for evaluation of his capability to stand trial but concluded that the appellant was able to defend himself.

'No question, whatsoever, was put by the learned trial court for its satisfaction,' the judge adds.

The judge observes that it is an inalienable right of every citizen to be treated in accordance with law as envisaged by Article 4 of the Constitution. The judge says Islam also gives a...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT